The Dislike Button
Over the past months/year, Facebook users have been clamoring for a “Dislike” button in addition to the “Like” button that exists. Imagine my surprise when I saw a page claiming to be “THE DISLIKE BUTTON***OFFICIAL APPLICATION”
I wanted to see just what was here, so I fired up VMware with a sandboxed machine, and created a dummy Facebook account.
First thing there was a giant image map made to look like Facebook. This ran under it’s own tab on the Dislike Button wall page.

The button it points to isn’t actually a button at all, but an image map that consumes the whole right side of the page. Clicking it expands a window asking the user to fill out a survey in order to download the app. The window was actually loaded from “the-dislike-button.com”. Loading the app in Firefox with Adblock installed prompted me with a message asking me to disable the adblock software before I could view the page. Interesting.
So I did. Then I got this:

See that text at the very top? Just what it says. $9.99 a month. The fine print below was even better:
“Summary terms: This is an auto renewing subscription service that will continue until canceled anytime by texting STOP to short code 70438. Available to users over 18 for $9.99 per month charged on your wireless account or deducted from your prepaid balance”
The survey was a 10 question quiz which then prompted the user to enter their telephone number to get the results. I entered a bogus 555 number and clicked through.
At that point, I got a number of other ads, a “mywebsearch” toolbar installer, followed by a few other popups.
Meanwhile, the Dislike Button app page is still waiting for me to complete my surveys. After clicking through whatever I could, I still didn’t manage to install the app. I can only imagine what would have happened then. (at the very least, this organization would now have whatever facebook private info I had posted.)
The strategy behind this isn’t new: Something is offered, which will be given after a free survey or the like, which collects the user’s contact info as well as inadvertently signing them up for purchases they didn’t intend to make. First time I’ve seen it on Facebook however.
What surprised me was the number of fans. Over 300k as of this evening.
So! Lessons learned? Be wary of disingenuous apps. My thoughts on Farmville or anything else aside, no app will ask you for anything other than a “install” button through the actual Facebook site. No surveys or anything required. Also, read the fine print.
For those of you who do have third-party apps installed, consider how they’re configured and what data you’re sharing with them. For a good guide on how to limit or remove apps, I recommend the excellent Ars Technica Facebook Privacy Guide.
When it comes to free apps or amazing offers, it helps to remember that “there is no such thing as a free lunch”. No one, (except for maybe the most diehard open source geeks =P ) sits and codes for days and then releases their app for free. Everyone has an angle, or something they’re getting out of it. Read the fine print, and ask yourself what the motive is. You’ll usually find the price soon after.
That’s not to say the price is never worth it, but when it’s your personal info or security at stake, it never hurts to ask.
Is this the Droid you are looking for?
I’ve been on a bit of a social media kick as of late, starting up a Twitter account and launching a new website. I place a lot of blame for that on my smartphone. Having slowly gotten hooked on the concept of mobile e-mail by my work Blackberry (gateway drug?) I planned on getting a Storm2 soon after it’s release. Reviews for the device were mediocre, but many were glowing in praise for Motorola’s Droid, the Google Android powered device also being offered on Verizon’s network.
“Why didn’t you jump on the iPhone?” you ask. Variety of reasons. For one, I’m not a big early adopter of personal electronics and social apps. Not sure why. My PCs are cutting edge, but I didn’t get an iPod till the 4th generation. The Droid represented my first foray into smartphones (aside from my work blackberry, and that was slow in coming.) In some cases it’s a lack of device maturity, in others, I fail to get taken in by the hype. It’s probably a personality issue; the more everyone jumps on something, the more unlikely I am to do so myself, an irrational thought that what’s suddenly good for everyone is, for that reason, not good enough for me or something. But I usually come around eventually, and that has it’s own rewards, in that I’m usually introduced to a more polished product.
So life has been different with a smartphone in my pocket. And with it has been the desire to use more and more of the “web 2.0″ everyone talked about so much, because now it suddenly makes sense. It’s far from a phone in your pocket, it’s a computer in your pocket, and with the cellular network, it’s having the world with you at all times.
I can share trivial things, quickly and with little interruption. “I saw this, and it’s cool.” Is it important? Probably not. But quick text and “status” updating apps such as Facebook and Twitter have made it easy to share the odds and ends we run into every day. The key to this though is not only the ability to share these things quickly and with little effort, but to read and absorb them with little effort as well. I think this last point is the more important of the two, and it finally clicked to me the other day that this is the reason Twitter is so popular. I can get very brief, simple updates from many people, and it all but takes a few seconds. This seemlessness is what makes is so much more convenient and appealing over a direct e-mail or phone call.
The result of this also is that we can rack up social points and time with people without having to establish a dedicated conversation over the phone or so, which isn’t always convenient. And it enables interaction with many people at once, instead of overly focusing on one.
That’s not to say that face-to-face time has suddenly fallen by the wayside. But for the times when you want to have trivial conversations with someone throughout the day, it’s a welcome development.
The information at one’s fingertips astounds me. I get traffic info on my phone. My fiancee e-mails me grocery lists. I have my full calendar with me in my pocket, which syncs to the cloud, and to my friend’s calendars as well if I wish them to. (Which is awesome when you’re planning for a group.) Ask a question, and I can wiki it on the spot.
On the techie side of things, the fact that 3G and cellular networks in general are becoming more and more like a general internet service is evident in it’s networking capabilities. I can tether a computer network to my phone, forward all of the traffic over an SSH tunnel to a proxy server at home, or any other number of things. (The ability to do this and establish a Remote Desktop connection on my phone still awes me.)
Of course, many of these things are not unique to the Droid. iPhone will do it, Windows 7 Mobile will do it, other Android devices will do it, as will Palm. Pick your poision. Eventually though, just as we saw with camera phones and color screens, we’ll all have one of these. I do find that rather cool.
There are of course, changes and consequences of any great technological change. Here’s a few I can think of just off the top of my head:
- The current regulatory climate is ill-prepared for these sorts of services. Cable networks, phone networks, cellular, and internet, are all regulated differently. But these services all ceased to be different a long time ago. All of these networks all run on Internet Protocol now, and all of them deliver some if not all of the services the other provides. The only differing mechanism is the physical medium easy service uses. Rules need to be drawn up for “Information Services” (since that’s what all of these are) and placed under that framework.
- Some commentators have been warning of security issues on the phone in the past. If they were early then, they arn’t now. This is a full-blown computer in your pocket, and has all of the same attack surface as your PC at home. As these are becoming more ubiquitous (and they are), this will become more and more of an issue. Smartphones, (which again, are really pocket computers) are not thought of as devices in the same class as a desktop or laptop. This will need to change quickly.
- Many privacy issues exist. I’m not necessarily talking about wiretapping. One of the key differences between your smartphone and your PC is that you control your PC. You have physical access to it, you can build your own, wipe it, load your own software, etc. It is your device, and so long as it understands Internet Protocol, you are free to control it as you wish. This is not true of your phone. With the exception of the few handful out there hacking apart Android, your phone company controls your handset. It’s features and functionality are ultimately delegated to you by your service provider. We’ve seen the dangers of network operators who abuse this control. It will need to be something that’s carefully looked at. Google’s Nexus One concept is promising in that it removes the provider from the handset, but it is by no means a total cure.
- We’ve seen these people: Persons talking on the phone in their car. Persons furiously typing away at their Blackberries in a meeting, elevator, or even while you’re talking to them. Extraordinary convenience creates extraordinary temptation to “check” on things every few minutes. I’m totally guilty of this. This is not a technological problem, but a human one. Self control. The recipient of a phone call or e-mail does not demand automatic response. People cannot expect an immediate response from you where you provide no expectation of one. This is an option I think people don’t exercise often enough.
That’s enough out of me for now. Do you have a smart phone? What do you use it for? What are you hoping to use it for? If you’re pressuring friends to get one (like I am. =) what are you hoping they’ll use it for? Post below!
Start
-knocks on the web frame- So whadda ya think? Isn’t much yet, but holds lots of promise. After sticking it out on blogger and hosting my own web server for a few years, I decided it was time to move to an actual host. Dyndns.org has been excellent in giving me the ability to host a web server from my own home, but getting around a port 80 block means doing some funky DNS redirects, something most corporate and government networks don’t take kindly to.
Also, I don’t have to remember to start VMware every time my system goes down for an update.
So here we are, all solid and stable and I don’t have to manage it. Which this time, is good. I settled on bluehost.com, who’s rate was pretty good. The control panel access and features are what sold me. I won’t be doing much development, but there’s support for more or less everything I’ll be needing (which isn’t much) and the premade scripts for installing wordpress and phpbb look great.
Speaking of WordPress, I’ve been insanely jealous of people’s blogs that seem well made and put together complete with easy to use widgets and twitter access and whatnot. Blogger is nice, but requires you to muck around with a lot of code to deviate from the template, and as you may have guessed by now, I’m no coder. Icons and buttons and check boxes for me, please. =)
So here it is, the new site. I’ll be hoping to post a bit more, some links and things, occasional funny stuff, interesting articles and the more occasional insight or dumb idea I just had. Given that I work primary in infosec now, there’s lots of instances I feel the need to comment on something, and all of the poor souls who read this page will now have to deal with it. =)
In the meantime, you web-enabled, social media twittering experts feel free to leave comments telling me what I did wrong or how to make this site look better. I now have the mandatory twitter account; I’ll eventually learn how to make the most of this thing. The rest of you, say something insightful!
Enjoy!
What I'm Doing...
- Loving this dreary weather. =) 1 week ago
- Still wondering why it is all of my pipes suddenly need to be ripped out...bbl, tearing up apartment. @Bent_Tree 3 weeks ago
- @EmilyHaHa Tripod or other stabilizer, tell them to smile and open their eyes "on three", dial back the flash. =) in reply to EmilyHaHa 2010-08-04
- Laura just booted up Dragon Quest VI....in the original Japanese...I had no idea she was so hardcore...=) 2010-07-16
- I was about to comment to Laura about how pretty the crickets and cicadas sounded outside, until I realized it was my external HDD copying. 2010-07-16
- More updates...
Powered by Twitter Tools